Long revered for its virtues in
reducing heart disease and amplifying brain wattage, salmon has
recently become the object of much attention. Like a host of foods
before it, salmon is now the subject of contradictory science. So what
is the bewildered, bemused individual to do, bombarded with so many
admonitions about what to eat, what not to eat, and how to eat it?To
begin with, lets look at why salmon has been recently criticized.
Around the world, scientists have claimed that salmon from fish farms
is among the most contaminated in the world. The study, published in
the Journal of Science, said British-farmed salmon is so full of
pollutant chemicals it should only be eaten sparingly. Eating more than
a meal of farm-raised salmon per month, depending on its country of
origin could slightly increase the risk of getting cancer later in
life, according to the study as farm-raised salmon contain
significantly higher concentrations of 13 organochlorine pollutants.
Among the most important are dioxins, which are released when
industrial waste is burned, and PCBs, once widely used as insulating
material. Studies have compared wild fish versus farm fish and have
found that there are 10 times as many PCBs in farmed fish, basically,
that's a reflection of how many pesticides; antibiotics and other
contaminants are used in raising them. Scientists from six research
centers in the United States and Canada, found chemicals linked to
cancer and birth defects in farm-raised salmon. However, these study's
conclusions are somewhat controversial since The Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) insists that the levels of pollutants in
farm-raised salmon are too low for serious concern.
On
the flip side, The American Heart Association advises eating fish at
least twice a week because it may help prevent heart disease. Salmon is
usually listed as a top choice because it is particularly high in
heart-healthy omega-3 fatty acids (a type of poly-unsaturated fatty
acids found in cold water fish such as salmon, mackerel, sardines, and
tuna). Omega-3 is an essential fatty acid which cannot be made by the
body but obtained from foods and is low in brain-harming mercury.
Furthermore,
salmon is an excellent source of complete protein providing all of the
essential amino acids. It is comparable to beef, egg or milk protein on
a biological value scale. It is easily digested and tests show that
85-90% of the protein is assimilable, making it a perfect nutrition
source for people of all ages. Approximately 100gram (3.5 ounces)
serving of salmon, will supply about 22 grams of protein, 1.4 grams of
omega-3 fatty acids, 10% of the daily allowance of Vitamin D, about 10%
of thiamin, 15% riboflavin and 50% of the niacin (which helps the body
absorb calcium) required daily. Salmon also contains elements such as
calcium, magnesium, potassium, phosphorus, sulfur, fluorine, selenium,
copper, zinc, and iodine. In addition it has far less saturated fat
than an equal portion of virtually any other meat or poultry. Its also
low in salt and has lower cholesterol levels compared with other lean
meats such as chicken or beef.
Salmons reported benefits are:Cardiovascular
Benefits. The most important types of omega-3 fatty acids found in fish
oils are eicosapentanoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). The
body needs EPA (the primary omega-3 found in salmon) to produce
prostaglandins, which are hormone-like substances that help to protect
the heart and the cell membranes. DHA is required for the normal
development of the brain, the eyes, and the reproductive system.
Moreover, its an excellent source to boost HDL (high density
lipoprotein) in your blood stream. These omega-3 oils protect the heart
by preventing the formation of blood clots and fatty deposits (plaque)
on the arterial walls. In people with coronary heart disease, fish oils
may help to reduce the risk of blood clots in the brain or in the
lungs; pain associated with angina; and the risk of cardiac arrythmias.
Basically, LDL (low density lipoprotein) is responsible for clogging
your blood vessels and HDL helps to exile the LDL to the liver where
its destroyed, hence its beneficial to have a higher level of HDL and
less LDL in your blood. A study chaired by Gary J. Nelson, Ph.D., of
the U.S. Dept of Agriculture's Western Human Nutrition Research Center
in San Francisco, showed that HDL increased by 10% by just eating 20
days of a high salmon diet. It is no coincidence that Japan consumes
the highest amount of salmon per head (among many other factors), and
has the lowest level of heart disease in the world.
Breast
Cancer. Eating even small amounts of salmon may protect against ovarian
and digestive tract cancers. Salmon may be especially protective
against cancer since this fish contains not only omega-3 fats, but the
trace mineral selenium. Several mechanisms have been suggested to
explain the cancer-preventive activities of selenium. Selenium has been
shown to induce DNA repair and synthesis in damaged cells, to inhibit
the proliferation of cancer cells, and to induce their apoptosis, the
self-destruct sequence the body uses to eliminate worn out or abnormal
cells. In addition, selenium is incorporated at the active site of many
proteins, including glutathione peroxidase, the most important for
cancer protection. One of the body's most powerful antioxidant enzymes,
glutathione peroxidase is used in the liver to detoxify a wide range of
potentially harmful molecules. When levels of glutathione peroxidase
are too low, these toxic molecules are not disarmed and wreak havoc on
any cells with which they come in contact, damaging their cellular DNA
and promoting the development of cancer cells. Four ounces of cooked
salmon provide 117.9% of the daily value for selenium.
Maintain
Mental Clarity. A study published in the January 2004 issue of
Neurology indicates a direct correlation between consumption of omega-3
rich fish such as salmon and tuna, and mid-life mental performance. The
five-year study evaluated 1,613 subjects ranging in age from 45 to 70
for memory, psychomotor speed, cognitive flexibility (i.e. higher order
information processing), and overall cognition. Eating omega-3-rich
fish several times each week was found to reduce the risk of impaired
overall cognitive function by almost 20% and speed by 28%. Frequent
fatty fish consumption also had a similar beneficial effect on
cognition.
Protection Against Alzheimers.. A study published in the
July 2003 issue of the Archives of Neurology found that compared to
study participants who rarely or never ate fish, those who consumed
fish at least once per week had a 60% lower risk of developing
Alzheimers disease. Researchers concluded that the two most important
factors for lowering Alzheimers disease risk were an individuals total
intake of omega 3 fats, and particularly their intake of
docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), one of the omega 3 fats found in cold water
fish (such as salmon).
Brain Food. The human brain is more than
60% structural fat. For brain cells to function properly, this
structural fat needs to be primarily omega-3 fats such as the EPA
(eicosapentaenoic acid) found in salmon. This is because the membranes
of all our cells, including our brain cells or neurons, are primarily
composed of fats. Cell membranes are the gatekeepers of the cell.
Anything that wants to get into or out of a cell must pass through the
cell's outer membrane. And omega-3 fats, which are especially fluid and
flexible, make this process a whole lot easier, thus maximizing the
cell's ability to usher in nutrients while eliminating wastes.
Decrease
Depression. Epidemiological studies in various countries suggest a
connection between increased rates of depression and decreased omega-3
consumption. It is thought that low levels of omega-3 are associated
with low levels of a brain chemical called serotonin, which contributes
to depression. Omega-3 fatty acids particularly DHA, are needed for
normal nervous system function. Researches from Erasmus Medical Center
in Rotterdam have found that depressed people have lower omega-3 fatty
acid levels than people who are not depressed. Low levels of the other
omega-3 fatty acid from fish, EPA, have correlated with increased
severity of depression.
Antagonistic Behavior. A study published
in the January 2004 issue of the European Journal of Clinical Nutrition
found a statistically significant relationship between consuming fish
rich in omega-3 fats and a lower hostility score in 3581 young urban
adults. Those with the highest intake of omega 3 fats had only a 10%
likelihood of being among those with the highest hostility scores.
Healthy
Children. In children, the relationship between low dietary intake of
omega-3 fats and ADHD has begun to be studied. A recent Purdue
University study showed that kids low in omega-3 essential fatty acids
are significantly more likely to be hyperactive, have learning
disorders, and to display behavioral problems, such as temper tantrums,
in addition to sleep problems.
Control Blood Pressure. Fish
oils, abundantly present in salmon, may help to control high blood
pressure, in addition to managing the symptoms of early rheumatoid
arthritis (RA). A significant reduction in joint tenderness, morning
stiffness, and fatigue, coupled with an increase in grip strength, has
been observed in patients.
Although theres no doubt that
fish is still a very nutritious food, and most experts are in
agreement, that the benefits of salmon far outweigh the hazards,
moderation they state, is the key to getting that beneficial omega3
fatty acid. You rarely find food good-bad, black or white. Its a little
more complicated than that. Given that, one should realize that long
standing research and a whole body of literature has demonstrated
unequivocally that salmon has immense benefits, and only recently have
reports surfaced that this particular kind of fish, raised a certain
way may, be bad for you. As individuals we must take full measure of
our own health when deciding what to eat, rather than relying solely on
the latest study. Since were all bombarded with so much information, we
have to customize it and take our own individual situation into
consideration.